On January 9, 2025, the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., was filled with solemnity as people gathered to honor former President Jimmy Carter. At 100 years old, Carter had achieved a legacy unmatched in U.S. history as the longest-living former president.
His memorial, however, became a subject of discussion for reasons beyond his illustrious life of service.
Close friends Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood performed John Lennon’s 1971 anthem Imagine during the service. While their heartfelt intention was clear, the choice of song sparked controversy online.
Many fans criticized the lyrics, particularly lines such as “Imagine there’s no heaven… Above us only sky,” as inappropriate for a Christian funeral in a historic cathedral.
Some attendees and viewers expressed their discontent, with one fan commenting, “At a devout Christian’s funeral, singing this is tone-deaf.” Others questioned how the song aligned with Carter’s faith, deeming it disrespectful. Criticisms ranged from the song’s message to the performance itself, with remarks about its execution.
