He told me to skip dessert because he only likes ‘skinny women’ — I chose confidence over his approval.

That is an incredibly rude, hurtful, and controlling thing for anyone to say, especially a partner. You made the absolutely right choice in prioritizing your confidence and self-respect over his cruel and superficial demand.

Al Pacino speaks onstage during American Film Institute's 45th Life Achievement Award Gala Tribute to Diane Keaton at Dolby Theatre on June 8, 2017 in Hollywood, California | Source: Getty Images

His comment reveals a problem with his character, not with your body or your choices.


 

💔 The Deeper Issue with His Comment

Al Pacino and Diane Keaton on "The Godfather" in 1971 | Source: Getty Images

A statement like “skip dessert because he only likes ‘skinny women'” is not about dessert; it’s about control, respect, and emotional abuse.

  • It’s Controlling: He was using food, a basic necessity and source of pleasure, as a tool to police your behavior and body size. A healthy partner respects your autonomy in making personal choices.
  • It’s Disrespectful: His comment directly criticized your body and implied that your value to him is conditional upon your achieving an arbitrary and unhealthy physical standard that he prefers.
  • It’s Body Shaming: This is a form of verbal abuse intended to make you feel bad about yourself, which often leads to poor self-esteem and harmful behaviors (like restrictive eating) as you desperately seek his approval.
  • It Reflects Superficiality: His preferences are so shallow that they override his respect for your feelings and your personhood. A loving partner would want you to enjoy a treat and feel comfortable in your own skin.

Woody Allen and Diane Keaton in "Annie Hall" in 1977 | Source: Getty Images


 

✨ Choosing Confidence is the Only Way Forward

Woody Allen and Diane Keaton in "Annie Hall" in 1977 | Source: Getty Images

Your decision to choose confidence in that moment was a powerful act of self-preservation. Here is what that choice truly means:

  • You Protect Your Mental Health: By rejecting his premise, you protected yourself from internalizing his negativity, which is critical for preventing body image issues and disordered eating.
  • You Set a Boundary: You sent a clear message that your worth is not defined by his preferences or the size of your waistline. This boundary establishes that he cannot use criticism to manipulate you.
  • You Embrace Autonomy: Your body, your choices. Choosing dessert was a simple, yet profound, affirmation of your right to decide what you consume and how you live without needing his permission.
  • You Prioritize Joy: A healthy life includes pleasure and enjoyment. Skipping moments of joy to meet a partner’s unreasonable, external standards leads to a small, miserable life.

Woody Allen and Diane Keaton in "Annie Hall" in 1977 | Source: Getty Images

You deserve a partner who celebrates you, trusts your choices, and finds you attractive exactly as you are—not conditional upon deprivation or adherence to a narrow beauty standard. This kind of comment is often an early sign of deeper issues in a relationship.

Do you want to talk about how to address this comment with him, or perhaps discuss the next steps for a relationship where criticism like this is present?